Policies
Journal Subject: Library & Information Science
Peer Review Policy
The Journal of Scholarly Research and Metrics (JSRM) is committed to a rigorous, fair, transparent and unbiased peer-review process that ensures the quality, originality, validity and integrity of the research it publishes.
Peer Review Model
JSRM uses double-anonymous peer review:
- Authors do not know the identity of the reviewers.
- Reviewers do not know the identity of the authors.
- Editorial decisions are based solely on the scholarly merit of the manuscript.
Initial Editorial Assessment
Every submitted manuscript undergoes an initial assessment by the Editorial Office and one of the Editors-in-Chief to determine whether it:
- falls within the journal's aims and scope;
- meets the journal's basic quality standards;
- complies with submission requirements, including anonymisation; and
- adheres to publication ethics and research integrity principles, including similarity screening.
Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or declined without external review (desk rejection).
Reviewer Selection
Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment are sent to at least two independent reviewers with appropriate expertise. Reviewers are selected by the handling editor on the basis of subject expertise, research experience, publication record, availability and absence of conflicts of interest.
Reviewers must declare any conflict of interest before accepting an invitation. Reviewers suggested by authors are checked for conflicts of interest, and every manuscript is reviewed by at least one reviewer who was not suggested by the authors.
Review Criteria
Reviewers assess originality and novelty; scientific and scholarly quality; methodological rigour; accuracy of analysis; validity of conclusions; clarity of presentation; relevance to the journal's scope; ethical compliance; and the quality of references and supporting evidence. For bibliometric, scientometric and review studies, reviewers also assess the transparency and reproducibility of the data source, search strategy, time span, inclusion and exclusion criteria and analysis tools.
Editorial Decisions
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. Possible decisions are: Accept; Revisions Required (minor revision); Resubmit for Review (major revision, with further review); and Decline.
Final editorial decisions are made by one of the two Editors-in-Chief, based on the reviewers' reports and, where needed, advice from the Editorial Board. An editor with a conflict of interest in a manuscript is excluded from its handling and decision.
Revision Process
Where revisions are requested, authors submit a revised manuscript and a point-by-point response to reviewers. Where a reviewer recommends "Resubmit for Review", the revised manuscript is normally returned to that reviewer before a final decision. Where an editor decides without further review, the reasons are recorded.
Timelines
The journal aims to give a first decision within 4–6 weeks of submission. Reviewers are normally asked to respond to an invitation within 7 days and to complete the review within 14 days of accepting it.
Confidentiality
All manuscripts are confidential. Editors and reviewers must not disclose, distribute or use unpublished content except for the review process, and must not upload manuscripts or any part of them to generative AI tools or other online services.
Special Issues
Special-issue manuscripts follow the same double-anonymous peer review and editorial standards as regular submissions, with at least two independent reviewers. Guest editors do not handle manuscripts on which they are an author or have a conflict of interest; these are handled by an Editor-in-Chief or another editor. Final decisions on all special-issue papers rest with the Editors-in-Chief.
Appeals
See Complaints and Appeals under Editorial Policies.
Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
JSRM follows the Core Practices and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and handles suspected misconduct using the COPE flowcharts. All parties – authors, editors, reviewers and the publisher – are expected to meet the standards below.
Responsibilities of Authors
- Submit original work that has not been published before and is not under consideration elsewhere.
- Present methods, data and findings accurately and honestly.
- Cite and acknowledge the work of others properly, and obtain permission for any third-party material.
- Obtain ethics approval and informed consent where required.
- Disclose funding, conflicts of interest and any use of generative AI.
- Report significant errors found after publication and cooperate with corrections or retractions.
Responsibilities of Editors
- Make fair, impartial decisions based only on scholarly merit, without regard to the authors' race, gender, religion, nationality, institution or other personal characteristics.
- Keep all submissions and the identities of reviewers confidential.
- Declare conflicts of interest and withdraw from handling affected manuscripts.
- Protect the integrity of peer review and respond promptly to ethical concerns.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers follow the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers and the journal's Reviewer Guidelines, including confidentiality, impartiality, declaration of conflicts of interest and the ban on uploading manuscripts to AI tools.
Responsibilities of the Publisher
ScholarVista Private Limited supports the journal's editorial independence, provides the publishing infrastructure, ensures long-term preservation, and works with the editors to correct, retract or add notices to published articles when required. The publisher does not take part in editorial decisions.
Authorship and Contributorship
All listed authors must have made a substantial intellectual contribution, helped draft or revise the work, approved the final version and accepted responsibility for it, in line with ICMJE criteria. Author contributions are described using the CRediT taxonomy. Changes to the author list after submission require the written agreement of all authors and the approval of the Editor-in-Chief. AI tools cannot be authors.
Conflicts of Interest
Authors, reviewers and editors must disclose any financial, institutional, professional or personal relationship that could influence, or appear to influence, the editorial process or the interpretation of the research. Authors' declarations are published with the article.
Plagiarism and Similarity Screening
All submitted manuscripts are screened for text similarity during the initial editorial assessment. Similarity reports are assessed by the editors and are not judged by a percentage alone. Plagiarism, self-plagiarism, duplicate or redundant publication, unattributed use of copyrighted material and inappropriate text recycling are not acceptable.
Data Integrity and Image Manipulation
Data must not be fabricated, falsified, manipulated or selectively reported. Images and figures must not be altered in a way that misrepresents the original data.
Citation Manipulation
Excessive self-citation, citation stacking and coercive citation by editors or reviewers are not acceptable. Reviewers may suggest literature only where genuinely needed.
Research Involving Human Participants or Animals
Research involving human participants or animals must comply with applicable ethical standards and institutional or national regulations. Authors must provide the name of the approving ethics committee and the approval reference, and state how informed consent was obtained.
Where no ethics committee or institutional review board is available, authors must explain this in the Ethics Approval Statement and describe how informed consent, anonymity and data protection were ensured. The editors decide whether the study can be considered.
Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies
Authors must disclose any use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in preparing the manuscript, including language editing, analysis, coding and the creation of figures. The disclosure must name the tool and describe its purpose, and must appear on the Title Page under "Declaration of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies". If no such tools were used, state "None".
AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality and integrity of all content, including any content produced with AI assistance. Reviewers and editors must not upload manuscripts or any part of them to generative AI tools.
Handling of Misconduct
Potential misconduct includes plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication or falsification, image or citation manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, authorship disputes and peer-review manipulation. Allegations are assessed fairly and confidentially following the COPE flowcharts. Where necessary, the journal contacts the authors' institutions. Outcomes may include rejection, correction, Expression of Concern or retraction.
Editorial Policies
JSRM is committed to an independent, transparent, fair and accountable editorial process.
Editorial Independence
Editorial decisions are made independently by the Editors-in-Chief and the Editorial Board without interference from the publisher, sponsors, funders or any external party. The publisher does not determine the acceptance or rejection of manuscripts. Commercial considerations have no influence on editorial decisions.
Submissions by Editors and Editorial Board Members
Editors and Editorial Board members may submit their own work to JSRM. Such manuscripts are handled by an editor who has no conflict of interest, follow the same double-anonymous peer-review process, and the author is excluded from all decisions about their own manuscript. The author's role with JSRM is stated in the published Conflict of Interest statement. Normally, no more than one in five research articles in an issue is authored by Editorial Board members.
Editorial Decision-Making
Decisions consider relevance to the aims and scope, originality, scholarly contribution, methodological quality, peer-review reports, publication ethics and overall suitability. Final decisions are made by one of the two Editors-in-Chief. An editor with a conflict of interest is excluded from the handling and decision of that manuscript.
Editorial Confidentiality
Editors and Editorial Board members keep all submitted manuscripts and related communications confidential.
Corrections
Errors that do not affect the validity of the findings are corrected through a published Correction. Corrections, Expressions of Concern and retraction notices are published as separate items with their own DOI and are linked to the original article.
Retractions
Following the COPE Retraction Guidelines, the journal retracts articles where there is clear evidence of research misconduct, plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication or falsification, unethical research or serious errors that invalidate the findings. Retracted articles remain online, clearly marked as retracted, with the retraction notice.
Expressions of Concern
Where significant concerns arise but evidence is not yet sufficient for correction or retraction, the journal may publish an Expression of Concern while an investigation is under way.
Article Withdrawal
Authors may withdraw a manuscript at any time before acceptance. After acceptance, withdrawal is allowed only for a serious reason (such as an error that cannot be corrected) and with the written agreement of an Editor-in-Chief. Published articles are not withdrawn; they may only be corrected or retracted.
Complaints and Appeals
Authors and others may submit complaints about editorial decisions, peer review, publication ethics or journal administration to editor.jsrm@scholarvista.in. Appeals against editorial decisions should give reasons and supporting information. Appeals are assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision. Complaints and appeals are acknowledged within 7 working days, and the outcome is normally communicated within 30 days. An appeal does not guarantee reversal of the decision. Unresolved concerns about publication ethics may be referred to COPE.
Open Access Policy
JSRM provides immediate open access to all its content, on the principle that making research freely available supports a greater global exchange of knowledge. All articles are free to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search and link to the full text, and to use for any other lawful purpose, without prior permission from the publisher or the author, in accordance with the Budapest Open Access Initiative (BOAI) definition of open access. Articles are published under the CC BY 4.0 licence. Neither readers nor their institutions are charged for access.
Copyright & Licensing
Authors retain copyright of their work without restrictions. Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) licence, which allows anyone to share and adapt the work for any purpose, provided the original authors and source are properly credited.
By signing the Publishing Agreement after acceptance, authors confirm that they hold the necessary rights to the work and grant ScholarVista Private Limited the right of first publication and a non-exclusive licence to publish, archive, preserve and disseminate the article. Third-party material reproduced with permission is not covered by CC BY unless its owner allows it, and is marked as such in the article.
Licence information: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) – https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Preprint & Self-Archiving Policy
JSRM considers manuscripts posted as preprints on recognised non-commercial preprint servers. A preprint is not considered prior publication; authors must disclose it, with its DOI or link, at submission.
Authors may deposit any version of their article – submitted, accepted or published – in any institutional or subject repository, or on personal websites, without embargo, citing the original publication in JSRM with its DOI.
Archiving & Digital Preservation
- Journal website: all articles are permanently available on the JSRM website (Open Journal Systems).
- Zenodo (CERN): every published article is deposited in the JSRM community on Zenodo with its Crossref DOI – https://zenodo.org/communities/jsrm.
- Crossref: article metadata and DOIs are registered with Crossref, so DOIs continue to resolve even if the website address changes.
- PKP Preservation Network: will be added once the journal's eISSN is issued.
Persistent Identifiers
Every article receives a Crossref DOI (prefix 10.68708). Author ORCID iDs are included in article metadata, and authors are required to provide an ORCID iD for the corresponding author.
Publication Fees
JSRM is a Gold Open Access journal. Readers never pay to access articles.
Current policy: JSRM charges no submission fee, editorial processing fee, peer-review fee, Article Processing Charge (APC), page charge or colour charge for manuscripts accepted for publication in issues up to and including Volume 2, Issue 4 (December 2027). Authors are not asked to make any payment at any stage.
Future fees: if APCs are introduced after this period, they will be announced on this website at least three months before they apply, will apply only to manuscripts submitted on or after the announced effective date, and will be accompanied by a published fee-waiver policy for authors who are unable to pay. Manuscripts submitted before that date will remain free of charge. Fee status never influences editorial decisions.
There is no charge for withdrawing a manuscript.
Ownership, Revenue, Advertising and Marketing
JSRM is owned and published by ScholarVista Private Limited, India (CIN: U58132DC2026PTC474053), an independent publishing company. Details of the company are given on the About the Publisher page.
The journal currently charges no author fees; its operating costs are met by the publisher. Any future revenue sources (such as APCs) will be published on this website in advance. JSRM does not carry advertising. Any direct marketing, such as calls for papers, is appropriate, well targeted and unobtrusive, and makes no false claims about indexing or metrics.
Data Availability
Authors are encouraged to make the data underlying their findings available in a recognised public repository (for example Zenodo, Figshare or OSF) and must include a Data Availability Statement. Where data cannot be shared for ethical, legal or licensing reasons (for example, Scopus or Web of Science exports), the statement should explain why and how the data can be obtained.
Privacy Policy
JSRM respects the privacy of authors, reviewers, editors and readers. Personal information collected through the journal website and submission system (such as names, affiliations, email addresses and ORCID iDs) is used only for submission, peer review, editorial communication, publication and journal administration, and is not shared for any other purpose.
Author names, affiliations and ORCID iDs of published articles are made public and shared with Crossref, indexing services and archives (such as Zenodo) as part of publication. Reviewer identities are never published.
Personal data are handled in accordance with India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 and, where applicable, the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Data are kept only as long as needed for journal administration, the scholarly record and legal obligations, and are protected by reasonable technical and administrative measures. Users may ask to access, correct or delete their personal data by writing to editor.jsrm@scholarvista.in.
Policy Updates
The journal reviews its policies regularly and updates them to reflect developments in scholarly publishing and COPE guidance. Changes are published on this page with the date of the update.
Last updated: November 2026
Contact
Editorial Office, Journal of Scholarly Research and Metrics (JSRM) – editor.jsrm@scholarvista.in