Journal of Scholarly Research and Metrics

For Reviewers

Journal Subject: Library & Information Science

Reviewer Guidelines

The Journal of Scholarly Research and Metrics (JSRM), a journal in Library & Information Science, relies on the expertise and commitment of qualified reviewers to maintain the quality, integrity and scientific standards of the journal.

Peer review plays a vital role in ensuring that published research is accurate, original, and methodologically sound.

Reviewer Eligibility

Reviewers should:

  • Hold appropriate academic or professional expertise in the subject area.
  • Have a record of scholarly publications or relevant research experience.
  • Be able to provide objective, constructive, and timely reviews.
  • Declare any conflicts of interest before accepting a review invitation.

Reviewers are selected by the handling editor for their subject expertise and must declare any conflict of interest before accepting an invitation. Reviewers suggested by authors are checked for conflicts of interest, and every manuscript is reviewed by at least one reviewer who was not suggested by the authors. Reviewer recommendations are advisory; final decisions are made by the Editors-in-Chief.

Accepting a Review

Before accepting a review invitation, reviewers should ensure that they:

  • Have sufficient expertise to evaluate the manuscript.
  • Can complete the review within the requested timeframe.
  • Have no conflicts of interest that may affect their impartiality.

If reviewers are unable to complete the review, they should promptly decline the invitation so that an alternative reviewer can be assigned.

Reviewers are normally asked to respond to an invitation within 7 days and to complete the review within 14 days of accepting it. If more time is needed, please inform the Editorial Office.

Conducting the Review

Reviewers should evaluate manuscripts based on:

  • Originality
  • Scientific quality
  • Methodological rigor
  • Clarity of presentation
  • Validity of conclusions
  • Relevance to the journal's scope
  • Ethical compliance
  • For bibliometric, scientometric and review studies: transparency and reproducibility of the data source, search strategy, time span, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and analysis tools.

Comments should be constructive, respectful, and evidence-based.

Comments intended only for the editor (for example, concerns about ethics or misconduct) should be entered in the confidential comments box in the OJS review form, not in the comments to authors.

Review Recommendation

Reviewers select one of the recommendations offered in the OJS review form:

  • Accept Submission – publishable as it stands.
  • Revisions Required – minor changes; the editor can check the revision.
  • Resubmit for Review – major changes; the revised version should be reviewed again.
  • Resubmit Elsewhere – outside the scope of JSRM.
  • Decline Submission – not suitable for publication.
  • See Comments – the recommendation is explained in the comments.

Reviewers who recommend Revisions Required or Resubmit for Review may be invited to assess the revised manuscript.

The final decision is made by one of the two Editors-in-Chief, taking into account the reviewers' reports and, where needed, advice from the Editorial Board. An editor with a conflict of interest in a manuscript is excluded from its handling and decision.

Reviewer Responsibilities & Ethics

JSRM follows the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers. Reviewers should:

  • Review fairly, objectively and independently, commenting on the work and never on the authors personally.
  • Treat the manuscript as confidential – do not share it, discuss it or use its unpublished content for any purpose.
  • Declare any financial, institutional, professional or personal conflict of interest, and decline if an impartial review is not possible.
  • Not try to identify the authors, and not reveal their own identity in the review comments or files (double-anonymous review).
  • Not upload the manuscript, or any part of it, to generative AI tools or other online services, as this breaches confidentiality.
  • Suggest relevant literature only where genuinely needed, and never request citations to their own work without clear justification.
  • Report suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, image or citation manipulation to the Editorial Office.
  • Complete the review within the agreed time, or inform the Editorial Office promptly if more time is needed.

Reviewer Recognition

JSRM values the contribution of its reviewers. Reviewers receive a review certificate on request and may record their verified reviews for JSRM in their Web of Science Researcher Profile (formerly Publons). The journal publishes an annual list of reviewers to thank them for their contribution.

Become a Reviewer

Researchers with expertise in the journal's scope are welcome to join our reviewer pool. Please register on the journal website, select the "Reviewer" role, add your areas of expertise and ORCID iD, or email editor.jsrm@scholarvista.in with a short CV.